Hi Best Cat! We take in abandoned or abused cats (we did dogs but had to stop now), and most of them will eat all the tins quite well, but I tried certain ones this time for a couple of real finicky ‘kids’. They didn’t eat the tins as much as they ate the large round Applaws containers. The one cat I was especially concerned about (a little manx), LOVED the pink tray of Applaws’, called ‘flaked tuna’. That’s a solid ‘YES’. They, like we, all have their own preferences!